Redfern On Giganto
Posted by: Loren Coleman on December 23rd, 2010
Today, Nick Redfern, as a guest blogger, reviews the new book from Mark A. Hall and Loren Coleman, True Giants: Is Gigantopithecus Still Alive?
Countless books have been written about Bigfoot, the Yeti, the Yowie and the Yeren. A significant number of words have been written about the massive, presumed-extinct, ancient ape known as Gigantopithecus. And, more than a few of those words suggest that the many and varied unknown man-beasts that are said to roam amongst us are examples of surviving, relic populations of that very same Gigantopithecus.
But what if something else, something even more fantastic in its implications than the idea that Bigfoot is Gigantopithecus, is actually afoot? That’s the scenario we are treated to in the new book from Mark A. Hall and Loren Coleman, True Giants: Is Gigantopithecus Still Alive?.
This is a book that, if you’re interested in Sasquatch and its hairy ilk, you’ll definitely want to read. It may not, however, be the book you’re anticipating or expecting. But, as I’ll demonstrate, that’s a very good thing.
The theory that Bigfoot, the Yeti, the Yowie (the list goes on) are indeed surviving pockets of Gigantopithecusis an attractive one. After all, at leastsome of the old stomping grounds of Gigantopithecus do broadly correspond to locales from where, today, we get reports of unknown, large apes. So, the theory does seem to make sense – at first glance.
The problem is that, for the most part, while Bigfoot and most of the rest of the hairy man-beasts among us are certainly big compared to the Human Race, they’re not that big. Creatures of 7-, 8-, or maybe 9-feet in height are typically what we hear of from those who are fortunate enough to encounter such animals.
But, just occasionally, a rare, rogue case will come along where the witness is certain that the creature they saw is far larger – maybe, rather astonishingly, in the region of 12-to-15 feet in height.
I’ve heard people say words to the effect of: “Well, sometimes, we see humans reaching 7- or 8-feet, so why shouldn’t there be a few over sized Bigfoot?” Fair enough, you might say. But, there’s another explanation too: we may be looking at different animals, rather than simply enormous versions of just one type. And, maybe those rare and rogue cases are not so rare and rogue after all! Cue True Giants.
So that there can be no misunderstanding of where they are coming from, Hall and Coleman note their position carefully, and early on, in the book: “These True Giants are not ‘Bigfoot,’ despite some efforts to make simple comparisons with creatures such as the one seen in the famous Roger Patterson-Robert Gimlin motion film of a Neo-Giant in California in 1967…They are of a different genus of primate.”
And it’s with respect to this different genus of primate that we get to learn so much about the truly massive Gigantopithecus in the pages of True Giants. The reader is treated to an excellent account of how Gigantopithecus came to be discovered and classified; its place in both zoology and cryptozoology; how and why the assumption has been made that it, Bigfoot and the Yeti are one and the same; and most importantly, why that assumption suffers from some major flaws.
And as the authors detail extensively and authoritatively in their book: a significant number of worldwide cultures tell of huge giants that once lived among us – the 12-15-foot-tall entities, and maybe a few taller ones, too. They were a marauding, violent breed, with cannibalistic tendencies, but who also seemed possessed of a certain degree of intelligence that allowed them to fashion a degree of clothing, crude tools, weapons, homes and dens (very often in caves or underground) and perhaps even primitive rafts and boats.
Of course, much of this flies in the face of accepted wisdom that Gigantopithecus, the True Giant, was just a huge ape. The theory that it could have been something more – something much more – is a controversial one. But it’s a theory that Hall and Coleman back up with a wealth of fascinating accounts from times past that encompass Asia, North America, Europe, South America and numerous other places, too. And, in doing so, the authors make a very good, thought-provoking case.
In fact, they are clear on the issue that dismissing Gigantopithecus as a gigantic ape is way off-track: “…the fossils that have been found for this particular giant primate have been attributed not to a giant man but, erroneously, to a giant ape…Some people have suggested that the fossils, known as Gigantopithecus, are gigantic men. We believe that view will one day be proven correct.”
And it’s with this viewpoint in mind that the pair provide us with some truly fascinating accounts that actually sit very well within just such a scenario. And it’s a point of view that provoked a lot of graphic imagery as I was reading the book.
Indeed, one of the things that really hit home upon digesting True Giants is how much of our own history we appear to have lost and forgotten – or that we have simply chosen to relegate to the realm of fantasy. Priceless tales of times long-past when gigantic beast-men roamed the world, perhaps competing with us for food, water, and a place to call home, fill the pages of this book.
But, numerous cases from the last couple of centuries and even up to the present day suggest that these huge, lumbering beast-men have not gone the way of the Dodo, but may still be found deep in the ancient forests, and the hard-to-access, huge mountain peaks that continue to dominate the wilder parts of our world.
In conclusion, True Giants is a book that is as groundbreaking as it is thought-provoking and paradigm-challenging. Hall and Coleman detail a remarkable theory – and a rich history, too – that serves to explain the many and varied accounts of huge, hairy giants in our midst. In the process of doing so, they weave a complex and fascinating story of something gigantic, something definitively monstrous but equally definitively man-like too, and something that has lived alongside us for so long, carefully shaping and sculpting our legends and folklore as it does so.
And, it’s very difficult to read True Giants and not come away with a deep sense of regret and loss, borne out of the probability that the full, fantastic history of these Goliath-like man-apes – and their ancient connections to, and interactions with, the Human Race – will likely never be known to us. However, unless or until we do learn more about not just the true nature of Gigantopithecus, but about our fog-shrouded history too, True Giants represents without doubt the best treatment we have thus far on this fascinating and engaging subject.
True Giants: Is Gigantopithecus Still Alive?
About Loren Coleman
Loren Coleman is one of the world’s leading cryptozoologists, some say “the” leading living cryptozoologist. Certainly, he is acknowledged as the current living American researcher and writer who has most popularized cryptozoology in the late 20th and early 21st centuries.
Starting his fieldwork and investigations in 1960, after traveling and trekking extensively in pursuit of cryptozoological mysteries, Coleman began writing to share his experiences in 1969. An honorary member of Ivan T. Sanderson’s Society for the Investigation of the Unexplained in the 1970s, Coleman has been bestowed with similar honorary memberships of the North Idaho College Cryptozoology Club in 1983, and in subsequent years, that of the British Columbia Scientific Cryptozoology Club, CryptoSafari International, and other international organizations. He was also a Life Member and Benefactor of the International Society of Cryptozoology (now-defunct).
Loren Coleman’s daily blog, as a member of the Cryptomundo Team, served as an ongoing avenue of communication for the ever-growing body of cryptozoo news from 2005 through 2013. He returned as an infrequent contributor beginning Halloween week of 2015.
Coleman is the founder in 2003, and current director of the International Cryptozoology Museum in Portland, Maine.
Very good review by Nick. Looks as if I’m going to have to get a copy of True Giants to read.
I wanted to like the book more than I did. It is, as Nick says, the best treatment of the subject (really the only one), and he’s right in commending Loren and Mark for having the nerve to face it head-on. And the authors are upfront about the animal posing some physiological difficulties (there’s a reason humans never reach nine feet and healthy humans never reach eight feet). But even considering that we know little of Gigantopithecus, accepting its evolution into a primate as tall as a giraffe demands much better evidence than even Loren and Mark, prodigious researchers though they are, can bring to bear here. Any sort of True Giant seems a much greater reach than sasquatch.